Pin it
I've perfected my Reuben Sandwich over time and want to pass on my tricks for getting the ideal mix of juicy corned beef, melty Swiss cheese, zesty sauerkraut, and creamy Thousand Island spread between crispy rye slices. After countless attempts, I've nailed down what makes this sandwich truly special.
Fascinating Background
The sandwich's beginnings remain contested. Now it's a much-loved favorite across America.
Essential Components
- Corned Beef: Grab quality deli-sliced cuts
- Sauerkraut: Properly drained for that zingy flavor
- Swiss Cheese: Ideal for fantastic meltability
- Rye Bread: Classic with caraway seeds
- Thousand Island: Adds that smooth, rich finish
Simple Instructions
- First Things First
- Slather dressing liberally on both bread pieces
- Stack Smartly
- Build with meat, cheese and kraut in balanced layers
- Brown Beautifully
- Cook in buttered skillet at medium flame
- Complete Properly
- Apply light pressure to help the cheese melt through
Top Protein Pick
Good corned beef makes all the difference. Opt for fresh deli cuts over packaged options.
Pin it
Smart Preparation
Get rid of excess moisture from sauerkraut. Cheese melts smoothly when not cold from the fridge.
Ideal Heat Setting
Cook slowly on medium-low for a nice exterior. This lets everything warm up inside too.
Advance Planning
Get everything ready and keep separate. Only put it all together when you're ready to cook.
How To Serve
Slice from corner to corner to show off what's inside. Eat right away while hot.
Great Accompaniments
Add a crunchy dill pickle and potato chips. A small side of slaw works great with the rich sandwich.
Pin it
Tasty Twists
Switch corned beef for turkey or pastrami. Try different cheeses for new taste combos.
Bread Options
Go with dark or swirled rye traditionally. Just make sure it's thick enough to handle all fillings.
Special Trick
Don't forget to coat the outer bread with butter. This creates that amazing crispy exterior.
Mind Your Cooking
Take it slow instead of rushing. A gentle approach cooks everything through nicely.
Strategic Building
Put cheese right against the bread as a barrier. Then add meat and sauerkraut in the middle.
Pin it
Don't Squish Too Hard
Push down lightly while it cooks. Pressing too hard pushes all the good stuff out.
Quick Tidying
Put some baking paper down first. It'll catch any drips and save you cleaning time.
Feeding Friends
Try a large flat cooking surface for multiple sandwiches. Great when you need to feed several people.
Using Extras
Keep unused ingredients apart to stay fresh. Put together new sandwiches when you want them.
Deli Excellence
When done right, you get amazing taste in every bite. Just like from your favorite sandwich shop.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why dry the sauerkraut first?
Getting rid of extra moisture keeps the bread crisp and stops sogginess when grilling.
- → Can I use another protein?
Sure, swap in turkey or pastrami, but keep in mind it won't quite taste like the original.
- → What kind of corned beef is best?
Head to the deli counter for freshly sliced corned beef. If you've made your own, that's even better.
- → Is sauerkraut a must?
If you’re not a fan, go with shredded lettuce or coleslaw instead for a different twist.
- → Why not grill too hot?
Lower heat melts the cheese and warms the ingredients perfectly, while keeping the bread golden, not burnt.
Conclusion
A warm and crispy sandwich filled with corned beef, sauerkraut, gooey Swiss cheese, and Thousand Island on rye.